Why IS There CSRS and FERS, and How Do They Differ?

The Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS), established in 1920 by a congressional statute, is a defined benefit plan to which the government and employees contribute. The formula used to calculate the retirement benefit of each employee took into account both base pay and years of service.

CSRS was a forward-looking strategy for employee welfare funded by contributions from both employees and the government at a time when nearly all retired staff received a pat on the back, farewell waves, and, if highly placed in the agency, a gold pocket watch. When CSRS was established in 1935, Social Security, which most employees now rely on, was not yet in existence.

Contrary to the CSRS, where retiree cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) are made every year irrespective of the age at which an employee retires, FERS retirees typically do not receive a COLA on their annuities until they turn 62 and become qualified for a regular Social Security benefit. However, special-category employees with shorter careers and obligatory retirements, like police officers and firefighters, are given an exception.

When the FERS statute was created, it was believed that if—and this is a huge if—the FERS employees contributed 5% of their pay into the TSP, they would earn retirement income roughly equal to that of CSRS retirees, based on their years of service (with matching contributions from the government).

FERS employees can surpass their CSRS colleagues by making the maximum annual contribution, even without matching government contributions.

How has it performed?

It is hardly surprising that CSRS employees, whose annuities can be precisely computed, typically receive more benefits. Especially if they made contributions to TSP, FERS employees, on the other hand, only know for sure what the annuity and special retirement supplement (SRS) would be.

They would be eligible for the SRS amount of Social Security payment at age 62. However, they would not receive COLAs on the benefits until hitting age 62, when Social Security payment starts.

Additionally, whatever income they could take out of their TSP account would be based not only on the amount they had invested over the years but also on how well those assets had done.

The CSRS employees’ defined benefit plan was replaced by one that necessitates that FERS employees contribute to their retirement and hope that all those investments perform well. Employees under FERS who can invest the required amount and effectively manage their investments show that the program’s designers were correct in thinking they could compete with a CSRS employee.

However, those FERS employees who cannot afford to invest at the necessary level and/or don’t manage their investments well will begrudge the day this decision was made.

Differences between CSRS and FERS

  • Age at Which You Can Retire

FERS employees who started their jobs in 1970 or after must wait until they are 57 years old to retire, whereas CSRS workers can do so as early as 55. More senior FERS employees can retire a little sooner, depending on when their careers began.

  • Cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs)

Cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) have always been provided to older employees covered by CSRS. FERS employees become eligible for a more restrictive COLA when they turn 62. The COLA is equivalent to the benefits received by Social Security recipients and retired military personnel.

The FERS plan is typically regarded as having the advantage in this situation, at least for employees who have accrued more than 18 months of service. CSRS benefits are somewhat higher, and employees are not generally eligible for Social Security disability because they lack enough Social Security credits.

  • Survivors’ Benefits

CSRS employees’ survivors are eligible for survivor benefits at 55% of the initial, unreduced CSRS benefits. After a 10% decline, it falls to 50% for FERS survivors. However, survivors of FERS would typically also be entitled to Social Security survivor benefits and would most likely inherit the remaining amount of the Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) programs.

  • Annuity Payment Size

Since FERS is divided into three parts, each part provides retirees with less money. In contrast to FERS retirees who receive an annuity, a Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), and Social Security payments, CSRS retirees receive an annuity payment intended to be their sole source of income.

  • Regulations for TSPs

The federal government makes 1% of each FERS employee‘s contribution to their TSP account. The U.S. government will match further payments made by FERS employees up to a predetermined proportion.

Contact Information:
Email: Betty@PSREducators.com
Phone: 8889193252

Free Retirement Benefits Analysis

Federal Retirement benefits are complex. Not having all of the right answers can cost you thousands of dollars a year in lost retirement income. Don’t risk going it alone. Request your complimentary benefit analysis today. Get more from your benefits.

I want more

Betty Morales, Federal Employee, Federal Employee Benefits, Federal Employee Retirement, Retirement 0

Avoid Making These Federal Retirement Mistakes

Several things could ruin your retirement in the short or long term. Most of these, if not addressed in advance,...

READ MORE
Betty Morales, Federal Employee, Federal Employee Benefits, Federal Employee Retirement, Retirement 0

Three Social Security errors that retirees should avoid at all costs

Social Security is the largest federal program in the US. Benefit payments are made to almost 66 million Americans each...

READ MORE
Betty Morales, Federal Employee, Federal Employee Benefits, Federal Employee Retirement, Retirement 0

Health Benefits in Retirement: A Guide for Federal Employees

Health Benefits in Retirement: A Guide for Federal Employees Key Takeaways: Medicare, FEHB, and long-term care insurance are essential components...

READ MORE
Betty Morales, Federal Employee, Federal Employee Benefits, Federal Employee Retirement, Retirement 0

Early Bird or Night Owl? Maximizing Your Federal Retirement Payout

Early Bird or Night Owl? Maximizing Your Federal Retirement Payout Key Takeaways: Start early, contribute consistently, and explore tax-efficient withdrawal...

READ MORE